Leonard Arrington is known for producing some of the most important scholarly work on Mormonism during the twentieth-century, and for being the father or grandfather intellectually speaking of almost every historian of Mormonism over the last several decades. The first academic to be given the title “Church Historian” by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (no one who previously held the position was a trained historian), he worked in that position from 1972-1982 and was, with many of his colleagues in the history department of the LDS Church, subsequently moved to Brigham Young University to help start the Joseph Fielding Smith Institute for Church History. Arrington’s departure from the historical department of the church and move to BYU came after it went public that there were disagreements and some infighting within the church hierarchy over what kind of history should be allowed to be written, who should be allowed to write it, and what kind of access to the historical manuscripts held by the church should be allowed to not only outsiders but insiders as well. This is all well documented in Arrington’s book Adventures of a Church Historian.
One interesting note that I recently came across in Arrington’s papers, that I have not seen mentioned in his diaries or a recent biography, is the possibility that Arrington was spied on while teaching at Brigham Young University in order to ensure that he wasn’t teaching anything too liberal. This is fascinating in light of the fact that at least a few employees in BYU’s Religious Education department had the same experience as recently as four years ago. If it is true that Arrington was also recorded then this suggests a decades-long tradition of BYU professors being recorded and spied on. That maybe this has happened not just every once in a while when a rogue administrator has feelings similar to Ernest Wilkinson’s, but a continuous attempt since Wilkinson to have near complete control over what is presented in the classroom.
The document itself is only a small piece of scratch paper. In Arrington’s hand the document says:
“Acc. to Jay Bell, David Handy was asked to spy on me at BYU class with a tape. 6/12/98”
I have a good idea who Jay Bell is, may he rest in peace. I do not know for sure, though, who David Handy might be. If you know who he is would you be able to share either here or send an email to yakovbentov at yahoo dot com? Thank you in advance for your help.
4 Replies to “Your Help Please: Who Was Surveilling Leonard Arrington While He Worked at BYU?”
One obvious place to start looking is to find what BYU faculty members were reporting to the Strengthening Church Members Committee during the 1985-on era.
Good luck snooping.
It’s hard to find knowledgeable people for this subject, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about!
Possibly this guy? He was not a student then , but he may have had some connection as an alumni.
There is a David Handy who is currently conducting “faith promoting” tours of Central American for LDS travelers. Here is an excerpt from an email upon which I was copied.
From: “David Handy”
Date: March 28, 2019 at 4:55:09 PM MDT
Subject: YUCATAN REVEALED – Possible 2020 Tours for Evidences of Christ in Mesoamerica