I Desire to Dwell Among This People

In 1219 Francis of Assisi traveled to Damietta, Egypt, in order to convert Sultan Malek al-Kamel and avoid the Fifth Crusade.  He did not baptize the sultan but he did work out a peace treaty which was later rejected by his fellow Christians.  He also spend time in Egypt and in the Holy Land ministering to the needy regardless of creed.

After Francis returned he drew up a Rule for those who were to join him as Franciscans.  This document is called the First Rule, or, because it was rejected by Pope Honorious III, the regula non bullata (Rule not ratified by papal bull).  According to official reports, the pope rejected Francis’ first effort because it was too austere.  The real reason, however, may lie in the way in which his experience among the Muslims was reflected in the First Rule.

Chapter 16 is titled “On traveling among Saracens and other infidels.”  Francis laid out two options for his brothers if they found themselves directed to preach the gospel among the Muslims.  One way was for to the brother to preach the word of God when he discerned that it would please God for him to do so. Others had tried this, however, and with the battlelines so firmly fixed between Christians and Muslims its utility was suspect.

The other way is likely to be of some special interest to Latter-day Saints.  Francis’ first choice was that his brothers who traveled and lived among the Muslims should “cause no arguments nor strife, but be subject “to every human creature for God’s sake” (1 Pt 2:13) and confess themselves to be Christians.”  This appears to be the course Francis himself chose, after he left the sultan’s court as he worked his way back home.

Clearly, Francis’ understanding of the needs of the Saracen mission was grounded in the humility and service that marked the life of Jesus as the One who “took the form of a slave” (Phil 2:7) and thereby earned the honor of all of God’s creation.  Did this disqualify his Rule in the eyes of Pope Honorious III?  Possibly.  What is known is that the Rule submitted by Francis in 1223 was accepted, and in it Chapter 16 was reduced to two verses as an appendix.

Anyway, I am sure that this reminds you, as it does me, of the story of Ammon from the BoM.  On a deeper level, however, it also drives home the fact that God works everywhere and anywhere, according to his own will and pleasure.  And that is a very pleasant thought, for I am sure that if the ways, means, and goals were left to us we’d muck it up immediately.

5 Replies to “I Desire to Dwell Among This People”

  1. St. Francis was an interesting guy to say the least. There are at least two other parallels to Ammon I can think of. St. Francis left his inheritance, had he stayed on he would have inherited his father’s lucrative cloth trade. Second, he and his followers went where the other clergy did not want to go, the cities.

    My favorite story of St Francis is how he and his followers would decide where they were going for the day. Wanting to follow God’s guidance, not their own, they would spin around until they fell down. At that point they would stand up and face forward, that was the direction God wanted them to go. Now that’s trying to follow the Spirit!

  2. Elder David A. Bednar

    Can we sense the grace and strengthening power of Christ in the testimony of Ammon? “Yea, I know that I am nothing; as to my strength I am weak; therefore I will not boast of myself, but I will boast of my God, for in his strength I can do all things; yea, behold, many mighty miracles we have wrought in this land, for which we will praise his name forever” (Alma 26:12). Truly, brothers and sisters, in the strength of the Lord we can do and endure and overcome all things.

  3. they would spin around until they fell down

    Heheh. I’ve not heard that one before and it cracks me up. Do we think that rises to the level of historicity, at least as that sort of thing goes in the 13th century?

  4. Minor correction, the source I was remembering does not claim that Francis himself spun around, but that an early group of Franciscan preachers used it as a way of deciding where to go. As to its historicity, I can just cite my source, lectures by Phillip Daileader, a medievalist specializing in the high middle ages.

    However, Francis did do something similar, he would just wander in random directions and preach to whoever or whatever he found. If that meant winding up in the woods and preaching to birds and squirrels, that’s what he did.

  5. LOL, yeah, that’s the way I heard it as well, with Francis out talking to the woodland creatures.

    Anyway, I wasn’t really questioning the story, since it’s hard to get much evidence from that period sometimes. Just wondering what you were reading.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *